Cellphone and headphone usage will be prohibited from K-12 campuses starting August after the school board passed an updated electronic devices policy 6-0 – Trustee Marianne Horton being absent – during the June 17 meeting.
“While it’ll be a very difficult adjustment for many,” Board President Misty Odenweller said. “I know it’s going to make an impact on mental health in our district for our students and educational outcomes as well, so I’m thankful.”
Trustees introduced the update accounting for House Bill 1481 enrolled May 28, requiring school boards prohibit communication device usage during the school day and implement mandatory discipline measures for violations.
Enrolled HB 1481
Similar to the current school policy restricting electronics during teaching hours, students may keep electronics in their backpacks, lockers or any designated areas; however, usage will now be prohibited during the entire day including passing periods and lunch.
“I supported this policy based on growing evidence that phone-free learning environments improve focus, reduce distractions, and improve student outcomes, especially for our most at-risk learners.” Trustee Melissa Semmler wrote in a Facebook post. “As a CISD parent, I’ve witnessed these challenges firsthand. While I know implementation may bring challenges, I believe, as a district, we’re united in our mission to do what’s best for students.”
Before voting, discussion on wording ensued. Trustee Melissa Dungan recommended earbuds and headphones be added to the definition of telecommunication devices. Odenweller turned to Interim Superintendent Dr. Ted Landry for his input.
“I mean you can’t use the headphones without the device,” Landry said. “You know, they’re attached with Bluetooth, So I’d assume that listening devices would be encompassed (in the policy.)”
Additionally, Trustee Lindsay Dawson disputed the disciplinary section, changing “telecommunications devices will be confiscated with each offense and held in the school office” to “may be confiscated,” intending to provide campus flexibility. Rewording this section allows campuses more choice over their implementation of disciplinary measures.
Returning Principal Dr. Jeffrey Stichler, who advocates for the policy, said those disciplinary measures are undecided as of now, but will likely include initial warnings while introducing the policy, with increasing consequence as the year progresses.
“While it is important for students to learn how to use technology, I would like to see them learn about, and how to use, the types of technology that they will use in their jobs,” Stichler wrote, mentioning the 2023 bond boosting technology resources. “I would love to see teachers and students beginning to utilize Chromebooks, laptops, and software to analyze deficiencies, make improvements, and prepare for the types of technology that will be used in the workplaces of the future (instead).”
